Glendale police say they intend to continue using automated license plate reader cameras even as several other Valley communities move away from the technology because of privacy concerns and reports of improper use.
The Glendale Police Department has defended its contract with Flock Safety, saying the cameras have become an important investigative tool that can help officers identify vehicles connected with serious crimes and locate suspects much faster than traditional investigative methods alone.
Glendale has used automated license plate reader technology for more than 20 years.
The city currently operates 58 Flock cameras positioned along roads throughout Glendale under a contract that runs through September 2027.
The cameras photograph vehicles traveling through their field of view and use technology to collect information associated with those vehicles, including license plate data that can later be searched by authorized law enforcement personnel.
Glendale had been scheduled to publicly discuss the system during an Oct. 1 meeting of the Citizens Transportation Oversight Commission.
Police were expected to give a presentation about the Flock cameras during that meeting.
The meeting was ultimately canceled because the commission did not have enough members present to establish a quorum.
The cancellation comes as automated license plate readers face increasing scrutiny elsewhere in the Valley.
Tempe, Surprise, Cave Creek and Chandler have all ended their Flock Safety contracts amid concerns involving privacy, data access and reports that license plate reader systems have been improperly used by law enforcement personnel.
Glendale police say they have no current intention of taking the same step.
Commander Scott Waite pointed to a recent homicide investigation as an example of why the department believes the technology remains valuable.
According to Waite, Glendale experienced a homicide approximately two weeks before the ABC15 report. Police were able to use the license plate reader system to identify and locate a vehicle associated with the suspected killer.
Within nine minutes, officers were following the vehicle.
Police argue that the speed of that response potentially prevented the suspect from having additional opportunities to harm other people.
At the same time, Glendale says it has implemented several restrictions intended to prevent officers from improperly using the enormous volume of information collected by the cameras.
License plate scan information is automatically deleted after 30 days.
Only approximately 20% of Glendale police personnel are authorized to access the system.
Officers who conduct a search must associate that search with a police report number.
Supervisor approval is also required.
The department says those restrictions mean only a very small fraction of the license plates photographed by the system are actually searched by officers.
According to Glendale police, officers review approximately 0.01% of all license plates scanned by the cameras during an average month.
Department leaders have also warned employees that unauthorized searches could have serious employment consequences.
Waite said Police Chief Chris Briggs has made it clear that anyone discovered using the system for something outside legitimate criminal law-enforcement purposes could lose their job with the department.
Glendale police also say the information collected through the system is not simply shared without restrictions.
Waite said camera data is shared when it is connected with an active criminal investigation.
Those safeguards have not eliminated concerns from civil liberties organizations.
The American Civil Liberties Union of Arizona is among the groups that have raised concerns about automated license plate readers and the amount of information the systems can collect about the movements of ordinary people who are not suspected of committing crimes.
The broader debate revolves around the ability of networks of cameras to create searchable records showing when and where vehicles have traveled.
Supporters say that information can allow police to quickly locate stolen vehicles, find missing or endangered people and identify suspects connected with serious crimes.
Critics worry that widespread collection and sharing of license plate information can create a surveillance system capable of tracking the movements of people who have done nothing wrong.
Those concerns have already influenced decisions in neighboring communities.
Chandler, for example, announced in August that it would discontinue its use of 40 Flock automated license plate readers after a routine audit identified an unexplained anomaly involving use of the system.
Chandler officials said the audit did not indicate that a member of the public had suffered a privacy violation, but the city nevertheless chose not to renew the contract while it reviewed policies, audit procedures and reporting requirements.
Tempe and Cave Creek have also moved away from their Flock programs, while other Valley communities have reconsidered how the systems are used and how data is shared.
Residents themselves can see arguments on both sides.
Lenore Griffith Bishop lives in Cave Creek, one of the communities that ended its Flock agreement.
She said she recognizes why police value camera technology because cameras are already common throughout communities and can help investigators follow the movements of a vehicle involved in a crime.
If a vehicle is seen committing a crime in one location and a Flock camera later identifies it somewhere else, she said that ability could be useful to investigators.
At the same time, she remains uncertain about how extensively the technology should be used.
For Bishop, the strongest justification is public safety and investigating criminal activity.
Her position reflects the broader debate now playing out across the Valley: whether the investigative benefits of a large automated license plate reader network outweigh the privacy risks created by collecting location information on millions of vehicles.
Glendale police believe their current rules strike an appropriate balance.
The department says the system has produced tangible investigative results, including the ability to rapidly locate people suspected of serious crimes, while access restrictions, supervisor approval, search logging and the 30-day deletion policy are intended to prevent inappropriate use.
For now, Glendale has no plans to join the growing list of Valley communities terminating their Flock agreements.
Police say they intend to continue operating the cameras while the program remains useful in criminal investigations and while department safeguards remain in place.
Source: ABC15 Arizona



