Parents looking to save money by purchasing secondhand baby gear may be encountering products that federal regulators have already banned or recalled because of serious safety concerns.
A new Consumer Reports evaluation found that unsafe children’s products remain readily available on major consumer-to-consumer marketplaces, including Facebook Marketplace, eBay, Craigslist and Mercari.
Among the products researchers found were padded crib bumpers and infant inclined sleepers, two categories that have been banned from sale in the United States.
Consumer Reports safety advocacy manager Oriene Shin described the findings as concerning, particularly because shoppers may assume an item is safe simply because an online marketplace allows someone to list it for sale.
That assumption can be dangerous.
The federal Safe Sleep for Babies Act prohibits the sale of padded crib bumpers and infant inclined sleepers. The restrictions apply even to older products manufactured before the law took effect, meaning the items cannot legally be resold through online marketplaces simply because they are used.
Padded crib bumpers are intended to cover the inside edges or slats of a crib, but federal safety officials have linked the products to suffocation and other hazards. The Consumer Product Safety Commission advises parents to keep infant sleep spaces clear, using only a firm, flat sleep surface and a fitted sheet.
Inclined sleepers intended for babies are also banned when the sleeping surface is angled more than 10 degrees. Federal safety guidance recommends that babies sleep on their backs on firm, flat surfaces in cribs, bassinets or play yards rather than in products that position them at an incline.
Consumer Reports examined how Facebook Marketplace, eBay, Craigslist and Mercari handle these and other potentially dangerous children’s products.
Researchers found banned or recalled products available across all four services.
The broader Consumer Reports investigation identified different banned products depending on the marketplace. Facebook Marketplace had listings involving crib bumpers, drop-side cribs, inclined sleepers and in-bed sleepers. Researchers found crib bumpers, drop-side cribs and in-bed sleepers on eBay, while Mercari had examples of crib bumpers and in-bed sleepers. In-bed sleepers were also found on Craigslist.
The investigation raised concerns not only about the products appearing online but also about whether buyers and sellers receive enough information to recognize that an item may be unsafe or illegal to sell.
Shin said many consumers simply do not know that some products have been banned or recalled. Because the listing appears on an established website or app, a shopper may interpret its presence as evidence that the product has already passed some type of safety screening.
Consumer Reports is urging the marketplaces to do more to prevent those listings from appearing in the first place while also giving both buyers and sellers clearer safety information.
Meta, which operates Facebook Marketplace, says its commerce policies require both buyers and sellers to comply with applicable laws and regulations. Recalled products are prohibited from being sold through Meta’s platforms.
The company also told On Your Side that it is taking additional steps in 2026 to address recalled merchandise.
Those efforts include adding recall warning labels intended to alert buyers and sellers and conducting sweeps of marketplace listings to identify potentially unsafe products.
eBay also communicated with Consumer Reports about the evaluation.
The company said consumer safety is a top priority and that it uses multiple safeguards and preventive systems intended to protect shoppers and maintain trust in its marketplace.
According to eBay, its product-safety algorithms prevented 21 million potentially unsafe listings from being posted around the world in 2025.
Mercari and Craigslist did not respond to requests for comment from On Your Side about the findings.
Consumer Reports says responsibility also falls on shoppers to investigate used baby products before bringing them home.
One product category that requires particular caution is car seats.
Shin advises against purchasing secondhand car seats because it can be extremely difficult to determine a seat’s full history.
A used car seat may appear perfectly normal while having been involved in a crash, stored improperly, damaged, recalled or used beyond its recommended lifespan. Important components may also be missing.
The same concern can apply to other types of used baby equipment.
Consumer Reports recommends checking the product label so buyers know the exact brand, model and item they are considering.
Consumers should ask sellers how long the product was used, where and how it was stored and any other information that could help establish its history.
Whenever possible, shoppers should inspect secondhand baby products in person rather than relying exclusively on photographs posted online.
That inspection should include looking for missing screws, pieces, attachments or other components that could be essential to the product’s safe operation.
Buyers should also check whether a product has been recalled before agreeing to purchase it.
Federal law prohibits selling recalled consumer products, including through online resale marketplaces. That means parents clearing out old children’s equipment can unintentionally violate the law if they list a recalled item without realizing its status has changed since they originally purchased it.
Consumer Reports found that marketplaces do not always make that information easy for casual sellers to find.
The organization’s larger evaluation found gaps in how the platforms explain prohibited products, warn sellers during the listing process and prevent questionable merchandise from being posted.
Consumer Reports says online marketplaces are generally in a better position than individual families to continuously monitor safety recalls, federal warnings and product bans. The organization is calling for stronger systems capable of identifying dangerous listings before they reach consumers.
For parents shopping secondhand, the central recommendation is to avoid relying solely on a listing’s appearance or the reputation of the marketplace hosting it.
A baby product can look nearly new and still have been recalled, manufactured under outdated safety standards or be missing a component needed to use it safely.
If a shopper cannot establish exactly what a product is, verify its history and determine that it has not been recalled or banned, Consumer Reports recommends walking away from the purchase.
Source: Arizona’s Family



