Dietary supplements have become a regular part of daily life for many Americans, but health experts say consumers can save money and reduce unnecessary purchases by determining what their bodies actually need before filling their shopping carts with vitamins, powders and other products.
Nearly 60% of Americans now use dietary supplements, according to a recent study published in JAMA Network Open that examined 25 years of data. With shelves filled with multivitamins, minerals, protein products, herbal supplements and other options, determining which products are worthwhile can become difficult.
Consumers also approach supplements very differently.
Phoenix resident Abdi Hussein said creatine is the only supplement he currently takes. Another shopper, Gianluca of New York, said recently turning 50 has made him consider taking some general vitamins. Will Hughes of Derby, England, said he does not currently take supplements but would consider using them if he had more information about whether they would benefit him.
Those individual bottles can quickly add to a household’s spending, particularly when consumers begin taking several products without first determining whether they actually need them.
Mckenzie Dryden, a registered dietitian with HonorHealth Integrative Medicine, says there is no single supplement routine that is appropriate for everyone.
Her first recommendation is to talk with a doctor or another health care provider before making purchases.
In some cases, that conversation may include laboratory testing to determine whether someone actually has a vitamin or mineral deficiency. Supplements are often intended to help prevent or address deficiencies, making it useful to know whether a deficiency exists before routinely spending money on a product.
Individual diets can also affect what someone may need.
People who follow vegetarian or vegan diets, have celiac disease, live with certain food allergies or otherwise restrict particular foods may have different nutritional needs than someone eating a broader diet.
Health professionals can also help identify possible interactions between supplements, prescription medications and other products a person is already taking.
That matters because dietary supplements are regulated differently from prescription medications. The Food and Drug Administration does not generally approve dietary supplements for safety and effectiveness before they reach store shelves. Manufacturers and distributors have primary responsibility for ensuring their products comply with federal requirements, while the FDA can take enforcement action when unsafe, adulterated or illegally marketed products are identified.
Once a consumer determines that a supplement may be appropriate, Dryden recommends looking beyond the price printed on the shelf.
A cheaper bottle is not necessarily the better value.
Shoppers should compare the Supplement Facts panels and ingredient lists between competing products, paying particular attention to the amount of each ingredient contained in a serving.
Two bottles may advertise the same vitamin or mineral on the front, but one may contain substantially less of the ingredient. A product with a lower purchase price could therefore provide less value depending on the serving size, dosage and number of servings in the container.
Consumers should also examine products for independent quality certifications.
Dryden recommends looking for certifications such as USP, NSF and Informed Choice. Third-party testing can provide additional information about whether a product was manufactured properly and whether its contents match what is represented on the label.
The National Institutes of Health also identifies organizations such as USP and NSF as independent groups that test dietary supplements. These types of certifications can provide useful quality assurance, although they do not guarantee that a particular supplement is safe or effective for every person.
Shelf life is another factor consumers may overlook when comparing products.
Different forms of supplements can remain usable for different lengths of time. Dryden noted that gummy vitamins generally have shorter shelf lives than products such as traditional tablets, capsules or powders.
That can affect value, particularly for someone purchasing a large container that may expire or lose quality before it is completely used.
Consumers should therefore consider not only the price per bottle but also the quantity they realistically expect to use before the product reaches its expiration date.
Ultimately, one of the simplest ways to reduce supplement spending may be to first determine whether the necessary nutrients can be obtained through food.
Dryden advises against relying entirely on supplements when a varied diet can provide many of the same nutrients. In some cases, adjusting what someone eats can be more affordable while providing other nutritional benefits that do not come from an isolated vitamin or mineral.
Hughes expressed a similar view while discussing his own approach to nutrition, saying that if someone discovers they are lacking something such as fiber, increasing fiber-rich foods may make more sense than immediately turning to a supplement.
That does not mean supplements have no role. Certain people may need them because of documented deficiencies, dietary restrictions, medical circumstances or other nutritional needs.
The larger point is that shoppers do not necessarily benefit from purchasing supplements simply because they are popular or marketed as generally healthy.
A smarter approach begins with identifying an actual nutritional need, discussing it with a qualified health professional when appropriate, comparing ingredient amounts rather than relying solely on price, checking for reputable independent testing and paying attention to expiration dates and product form.
For consumers trying to control both their health spending and the number of bottles in their cabinets, the biggest savings may come from figuring out which supplements are truly necessary before buying them at all.
Source: ABC15 Arizona



