Meta Platforms is heading into a major federal trial in California as four states seek substantial financial penalties and changes to how Facebook and Instagram operate, arguing that the company knowingly built features that can harm children and teenagers.
Opening statements are scheduled to begin Tuesday in federal court in Oakland. Attorneys general representing California, Colorado, Kentucky and New Jersey are bringing the case, which is part of a much larger legal fight involving social media, child safety and online privacy.
Those four states are seeking damages that could theoretically reach as high as $1.4 trillion, although legal experts have said a penalty anywhere near that amount would be unlikely. They are also asking the court to require changes to Meta’s business practices involving Facebook and Instagram.
The dispute began as part of a broader legal action filed in 2023. Twenty-nine states sued Meta over allegations involving children’s safety and privacy. The four-state case will be tried first, while the remaining 25 states are expected to proceed to trial later. Meta is also defending itself against separate cases filed in state courts.
At the center of the lawsuit are allegations that Meta deliberately designed features intended to keep young users engaged with its platforms even while knowing those features could contribute to mental health problems and compulsive social media use.
The states also accuse Meta of routinely collecting personal information from children younger than 13 without obtaining parental permission, which they argue violates federal protections governing children’s online privacy.
Kentucky Attorney General Russell Coleman has characterized the proceeding as an extraordinarily significant consumer-protection case. He argues that the states intend to show jurors that Meta knew about risks its products posed to young people but failed to adequately address those concerns because keeping users engaged was financially beneficial to the company.
Meta disputes the allegations and says it expects to present a strong defense.
The company maintains that it has invested heavily in protections for teenagers over many years, including safeguards developed before the current lawsuits were filed. Meta says it intends to show the judge and jury evidence of those efforts during the trial.
U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers will oversee the proceedings in Oakland. The trial is expected to continue for approximately six to eight weeks. Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg is expected to testify, along with other current and former company executives and employees.
Gonzalez Rogers has been a federal judge since 2011, when she was appointed by President Barack Obama. She has previously presided over several prominent disputes involving major technology companies.
Those cases include Epic Games’ legal battle with Apple over the company’s App Store and Elon Musk’s lawsuit involving OpenAI and its founders.
If Meta loses, the judge would have considerable discretion in determining the eventual financial penalty, meaning the theoretical maximum being sought by the states does not necessarily indicate what the company would actually be ordered to pay.
The case is one of many lawsuits confronting major social media companies over the effects their platforms may have on children and teenagers.
Meta is not alone in facing those challenges. Google’s YouTube, TikTok and Snap have also been targeted in litigation alleging that social media companies created addictive features, failed to adequately protect younger users and improperly collected information from children.
The Meta trial is expected to become one of the most closely watched tests yet of whether social media companies can be held financially responsible for the design of their platforms and their alleged effects on young people.
Source: ABC15 Arizona



